About
Citizen Voices is a blog about election politics, written by people like you. Six San Diegans give their personal take on the issues, candidates and propositions.
» Listen to their interviews on These Days
Categories
Recent Topics
americans andres serrano campaign children's pool seals chris ofili computers election elephant dung energy policies establishment clause faith fire first amendment holy virgin mary independent iraq judge larry burns mccain media mt. soledad cross national endowment for the arts obama off-shore oil drilling oil prices piss christ politics polls presidential presidential race religion religion and politics republican russia san diego southern california district taxes veterans for peace vietnam warVocational Warriors?
Last week, San Diego residents learned that Blackwater Worldwide has rented a large warehouse in Otay Mesa, allegedly for the purpose of training military and police officers.
The controversial company received a permit in March for a training site in Otay Mesa when it became apparent that Potrero was not going to allow them to build a facility in East County. They were able to gain a business permit from the Development Services Department by using the name of a subsidiary, Raven Development Group, and describing their business as a vocational training facility. (Raven has been in the business of designing and constructing facilities for Blackwater since 1997.) The permit was awarded without public hearings, in spite of the recent evidence of public resistance to such a facility.
Raymond Lutz, who is a candidate for California Assembly District 77, actively opposed Blackwater's presence in Potrero. His website, Citizens' Oversight Projects, tracks issues of interest to voters, including current efforts by Blackwater to gain a foothold in the sensitive border area.
Blackwater's new location is only a few blocks from the U.S.-Mexico border, and between two airports. Brown Field and the Tijuana Airport are both within minutes of their facility. It turns out the U.S. Border Patrol is just two doors down. Blackwater, in addition to their contracts in Iraq, is a recipient of a border-security contract awarded by the Bush administration, to provide wide-ranging support in global counter-narcotics operations.
Fortunately, three of our local representatives held a press conference last Friday to express their opposition to Blackwater's presence in Otay Mesa.
Rep. Bob Filner (D - CA) questioned the "vocational" nature of Blackwater's business. He described them as a mercenary army that has historically demonstrated that they are not answerable for their actions and he expressed concern for their lack of transparency. Filner observed, "Mercenary soldiers are a prelude to problems in a democracy... mercenary soldiers are the way people come to power, undemocratically". He called it "a dangerous, dangerous development... and not what our community needs."
Perhaps most passionate of the three was the address by Ben Hueso, councilman for District 8. "We don't know what authority has been bestowed on them by the federal government and even who is guiding them." Hueso, who has worked for six years to engender a spirit of cooperation between Mexico and the United States in this area, feels that a Blackwater presence is "contrary to everything we've worked for." He concluded his statements with a disturbing observation. "This is a private company that will profit from instability and insecurity on the border... it's of interest to them that we have conflict, that we have problems, because the more there are, the more they'll profit."
Council President Scott Peters said, "Blackwater does not share our community's values -- human rights, ethics and integrity and respect for the law." He also said he's concerned that they exploited a loophole in San Diego's zoning code and used a subcontractor's name on the permit to keep our community in the dark. Peters is a candidate for city attorney, so it is gratifying to see him step up to the plate on this issue.
Historically, the emergence of a paramilitary force has been dangerous to the rights of ordinary citizens.
We must ask "Who do they take orders from and who defines their mission? What controls are there on their actions? What is their true objective in planting themselves in this border region?" Without answers to these questions, we run the risk of abdicating our autonomy, just a little at a time.
Sound familiar?

Comments
In my nine years with the State Department’s Diplomatic Security Service (all before Blackwater existed) I participated in many contractor training programs, most of which were valuable. The use of contract training gives federal agencies the ability to offer expertise when it might not be be cost-effective to maintain full-time employees or facilities in-house.
While I can understand Hueso and Peters being confused and wanting more information, and certainly welcome Peters’ views about whether allowing this government contractor to provide these jobs in San Diego is appropriate for the character of the community, if Filner truly believes this is a threat to our country and not just an opportunity to grandstand it would be helpful if he would use his position as a member of Congress to propose and pass legislation to improve the situation, not just contribute to global warming.
Chuck from Escondido, CAMay 02, 2008 at 1:52 pm
As a resident of Potrero, CA, where Blackwater was recently given the boot, I can tell you that we were told many versions of the “truth” by Brian Bonfiglio, Blackwater spokesperson for the Blackwater West project...all delivered with a sense of entitlement, thinly veiled by a forced sincerity.
They want the huge revenue generated by the fear surrounding border security. He has publicly admitted to wanting to swallow the Border Patrol into the bowels of Blackwater, and does so with a self-righteous, nationalistic fervor.
The Potreroist from Potrero, CAMay 22, 2008 at 5:14 pm